Democrats Aren’t Significantly More Popular Than Republicans, and Their Push to Restrict Gun Rights Won’t Help Them.
Only a few weeks after the midterm elections left both major parties broadly unpopular, with voters especially furious at Republicans over the economy and perceived graft, Democrats believe they’ve uncovered an odd formula for staying in power: pivot to hot-button issues that are almost guaranteed to alienate large portions of the population. I’ve previously noted the Democrats’ renewed push against school choice, and now their base is also mounting attacks on self-defense rights.
You are viewing The Rattler from J.D. Tuccille and Reason. Get more of J.D.’s commentary on government overreach and threats to everyday liberty.
Americans Cast Ballots Focusing on Economic Woes and Corruption
In the wake of the midterms, NBC News polling showed that “many voters viewed the midterm contest as a rebuke of President Trump’s tenure.” Pollsters noted “an overwhelming majority” believed the economy was in rough shape (about 75%), and that government corruption also loomed large as a concern, though voters split on which party could best address it. In fact, most respondents expressed unfavorable views of both the Democratic Party (53 percent) and the Republican Party (59 percent).
It was an election where Republicans faced rejection, and Democrats were picked by default as the comparatively less problematic option. There was no broad embrace of a concrete agenda, just a hope that new faces would tackle worries about money, prices, and self-dealing.
Naturally, Democrats immediately pressed ahead with their war on school choice. Given the public’s broad support for education options, this move is striking and suggests that teachers’ unions, seen as hostile to school choice, enjoy more influence within the party than ordinary voters.
Democrats Ignore Public Demand, Double Down on Gun-Control Obsessions
Equally notable is the Democrats’ choice to revive efforts to disarm Americans at a moment when AP–NORC finds that “few voters (11%) listed ‘guns’ as a top-three issue motivating their vote this cycle.” There are few topics more contentious than how gun ownership and use should be regulated. And there is no issue more clearly driven by civic action rather than legislative debate; ownership and carrying of firearms has become increasingly common across a growing portion of the population. Going after guns is bound to inflame many voters Democrats need to stay in office.
Nevertheless, many members of the newly ascendant party are pursuing exactly those measures.
“Emboldened by their surprising majority in the Texas House after the 2026 elections, Democratic lawmakers have rolled out a wave of bills aimed at restricting gun rights in the Lone Star State,” writes Stephan Kapustka of The Texan. Among the proposed restrictions are a “red flag” law allowing judges to seize weapons without due process, a ban on semiautomatic rifles for 18–21-year-olds, and background checks on private gun sales that would be difficult to enforce. The package also includes firearm-storage mandates and a potential backdoor gun registry.
In Arizona, where Democrats gained control of both houses of the state legislature, Rep. Nancy Gutierrez (D–Tucson) framed gun-restriction measures as a top objective for the new majority. “Among the party’s main priorities, Gutierrez noted, are affordability solutions, protections for reproductive healthcare, and gun-safety legislation,” according to the Arizona Mirror.
Similarly, Georgia Lt. Gov.-elect Josh McLaurin has said the new Democratic leadership will push gun-safety policies, including a pediatric safe-storage requirement and universal background checks, per The Center Square. Gov.-elect Keisha Lance Bottoms has likewise voiced support for a ban on so-called “assault weapons”—semiautomatic rifles that some find intimidating in appearance.
Likewise, “Minnesota Democrats are preparing to make gun-safety legislation a priority again as lawmakers head into the 2027 session, now with control of both chambers and the governor’s office,” notes Caroline Weier of KAALTV.
On the national stage, as Chip Brownlee and Jennifer Mascia reported for The Trace, a publication critical of self-defense rights, the midterm landslide “unexpectedly opened up new avenues in states where tighter gun restrictions had largely been written off.”
Democrats Target Self-Defense Rights as Their Voters Embrace Gun Ownership
This strategy, to say the least, is peculiar. As noted above, gun issues did not top voters’ concerns before the midterms. In truth, rank-and-file Democrats have increasingly chosen to buy and carry firearms in recent years. “Across the U.S., gun ownership by people who identify as politically left of center is rising” largely because they view the Second Amendment as a safeguard against an overbearing government, Patrik Jonsson of The Christian Science Monitor reported in April of this year.
Democrats were handed an opening because Americans were unhappy with how Republicans exercised power. They appear determined to squander that moment just as the GOP did after the 2024 elections.
The Donkey Party Is Poised To Squander Its Opportunity
In 2024, YouGov polling found that “nearly two-thirds (64%) of Americans say inflation is a very serious problem.” Second on the list was corruption. If that sounds familiar, it’s because, as noted above, economic concerns and corruption remain at the forefront of American minds two years later.
Victorious Republicans responded to their 2024 win by pushing an agenda that included trade barriers that boosted the cost of living (lifting retail prices of imports by about 7 percent, per Tax Foundation studies), stringent immigration enforcement that quickly fell out of favor with Americans, and a continuing conflict in the Middle East that pushed up fuel prices. Worse still, as the midterms neared, AP–NORC found that “most Americans say President Trump has prioritized his own financial interests and those of people close to him since resuming office in 2025.”
Republicans neglected the issues that yielded them victory in 2024, focusing instead on their pet political obsessions. Democrats now stand on the verge of repeating that mistake by elevating their reflexive hostility to privately owned arms (and opposition to school choice) over the concerns that actually powered their 2022 election win.
Remember, Democrats have no mandate. NBC News reports that voters hold more unfavorable than favorable views of both major parties, the AP notes that the Democratic Party isn’t notably more popular than the Republican Party, and Pew Research finds the American public’s view of the two major parties to be more negative than positive, with a sizable share expressing disapproval of both.
If Democrats possessed sense and decency, they’d concentrate on areas where Republicans let voters down. But if they had such traits, they wouldn’t be politicians. As things stand, they seem determined to disarm Americans and to antagonize the very people who elected them.
Can Democrats Resist the Temptation to Deny Families School Choice?