School Board Member Probes How Churches Frame DEI in Messaging

November 16, 2026

The discussion revolved around several matters that touch marginalized communities, including the Church’s stance on same-sex marriage, the availability of safe and affordable abortion, access to gender-affirming medical care, the practice of conversion therapy for LGBTQIA+ individuals (youth and adults), and the availability of comprehensive sexual education and birth control for young people.

This dispute arose during a decision by the Hermon Board of Directors about permitting a church to secure a long-term weekend lease, under a policy that generally opened district facilities to community groups. On Friday, a federal court ruled that such a denial would violate the First Amendment. The following excerpts come from the lengthy decision in Pines Church v. Hermon School Department, authored by Chief Judge Lance Walker (D. Me.).

Plaintiff Matt Gioia relocated his family from Colorado to Maine in mid-2020 to establish a new church. Gioia was born in Waterville, Maine, and spent his youth in Guilford, Maine until finishing high school and enlisting in the military at seventeen. At first, The Pines Church gathered at Gioia’s residence. In March 2021, it began holding Sunday morning services at a movie theater in Orono, Maine, under a month-to-month lease. As the church grew, Gioia sought a space able to accommodate a larger congregation.

Gioia sought space from the Hermon School Department, which generally makes its facilities available to a variety of community groups:

This policy states that “[s]chool facilities should be made available for appropriate community use when such facilities are not required for their primary purposes: the instruction of students and related school activities.” The policy draws a distinction between “occasional or short-term use of school facilities,” which “shall be authorized by the school principal,” and “long-term rental or lease,” which “shall be authorized by the Hermon School Committee upon the recommendation of the Superintendent of Schools.”

However, the Hermon School Committee — made up of “Committee Chair Jesse Keith, Vice Chair Karen Shorey, Stephanie Oiler, Haily Keezer, and Christopher McLaughlin” — refused the Church’s request for a year-long or six-month arrangement, granting only a month-to-month lease, which seemed insufficient for the church’s need for a stable meeting space. Here is part of the factual summary drawn from the bench trial:

The day after a hearing, a former committee member emailed Keith and Shorey, suggesting that leasing a school facility to any religious organization might not be in the community’s best interests. The email warned of a quiet national movement by some conservative religious groups to erode the boundary between church and state, beginning with schools, and it warned that granting a lease to The Pines Church could set a dangerous precedent. It wondered how Hermon School Department would respond to a request from “an Imam who wants to open a mosque,” referencing the precedent set by the Pines Church lease.

Her message concluded with an unintended irony: “There’s a reason why the founding fathers wrote the constitution the way they did.” At trial, Keith and Shorey denied that this email influenced their decision regarding the church’s lease, yet the court found that claim implausible in light of the record….

McLaughlin reached out to [HSD Superintendent Micah] Grant with additional questions for Gioia, saying he “wanted to get a better sense of how [T]he Pines Church approaches issues of diversity, equity, and inclusion around their messaging around some key issues relevant to marginalized communities.” Those questions sought information about the Church’s views on same-sex marriage, “[a]ccess to safe and affordable abortion,” “[a]ccess to gender affirming medical care,” “[c]onversion therapy for LGBTQIA+ individuals (youth and adults),” and “[i]nclusive sexual education and access to birth control for youth.” …

At a later meeting, High School Principal Brian Walsh spoke about several concerns. He began by noting the difficulty of finding staff to clean the building on Sunday afternoons. Beyond that, he stated:

“We’ve never had a long-term lease, at least in my twenty-one years here, and I think there are a number of reasons we don’t do that. There are many variables we just don’t know. Our students come first, and our program comes first.”

“We also don’t know or have a sense of how this will be promoted, to [the student representative’s] question. If you attach Hermon High School’s name to a church or another organization with beliefs different from the school’s, I see that as problematic.” He added that this did not imply distrust of the church or its pastor, but stressed that the district had never approved such an arrangement, so it remained an unknown factor. He emphasized that there were too many variables and reiterated that long-term occupancy had not been considered before.

Later, Oiler moved to adopt a month-to-month lease, stressing concerns about the number of attendees and post-event cleaning, making clear that these concerns were about logistics rather than the church itself. Keezer asked whether Gioia could explain how the Church maintains its current space. Oiler argued that this discussion did not target the Church specifically (even though it did in effect), adding the less than persuasive point that if fifteen people fell ill at once, someone would have to take care of the mess. (Trial testimony later revealed that Oiler had a personal incident in mind involving Hermon Middle School, where her child studied.)

Given the district’s limited custodial staff, she framed the matter as a question of how many people would be moving in and out of the building. She suggested that the Committee should review its existing rental agreements to ensure other organizations were paying their fair share considering the costs involved. What this had to do with the church’s application remained obscure….

The Free Speech Clause forbids government restrictions on access to limited or designated public fora that discriminate based on viewpoint, including religious viewpoints. In other words, if school facilities are publicly available, denying access to a religious organization because of its religious nature would violate the First Amendment. Similarly, the Free Exercise Clause “bars even ‘subtle departures from neutrality’ on matters of religion,” and thus prohibits denying a generally available benefit solely on account of religious identity unless such denial serves a state interest of the highest order. …

Because of Policy KG, the Hermon School Department made its facilities available “for appropriate community use when such facilities are not required for their primary purposes: the instruction of students and related school activities,” including for “long-term rental or lease.” Having done so, the School Department could not then turn away the Church’s lease application due to its religious affiliation or disagreement with its religious viewpoints without violating the First Amendment, as the plaintiffs argued….

The court determined that the Department indeed violated the Church’s First Amendment rights by discriminating against it on the basis of religious viewpoint or due to animosity toward that viewpoint:

I begin by assessing whether a majority or a substantial group of committee members demonstrated improper motive.

I find with little difficulty that McLaughlin displayed improper motive. His intrusive inquiries expressed concerns rooted in the church’s religious perspective, and he was the sole member who voted against any lease term, including the month-to-month option. Although his email detailing political and cultural questions came early, even before counsel advised the Committee, and although he testified afterward that he bore no ill will toward the plaintiffs, the record makes it highly unlikely that he approached the lease issue with objectivity toward the church.

It appears that he would have treated a lease request from an organization sharing his own beliefs differently.

I also find that Oiler could not overcome concerns about constitutionally permissible school–church association, despite the legal guidance the Committee received, and despite Grant’s repeated emphasis. Although she did not appear openly hostile, her stance toward the Church was anything but neutral… [I]t struck me during her testimony, and I conclude, that her chief worry was the tenant’s identity as a Church. This became even clearer when she protested excessively that this was not about the Church but about fears, for example, of mass vomiting events and the need for a platoon of janitorial assistance to deal with them.

All of her other space-related concerns were addressed by Grant as not remotely problematic. I conclude, based on the trial record, that her motive was to prevent the School from associating with the Church because of its religious beliefs. The First Amendment protects against discriminatory treatment of religious organizations in receiving public facilities based on those beliefs or on speech tied to them. For this reason, I find that Oiler, like McLaughlin, voted with “bad motive.”

I also conclude that Shorey could not overcome concerns about a constitutionally permissible school–church association. At her deposition, she suggested that McLaughlin’s culture-war email was appropriate, even though she later tried to characterize it as inappropriate at trial.

Perhaps Shorey believed that a School Committee should be allowed to question a prospective tenant about how its values align with those of the school community, to the extent that the school community holds its own conflicting values that can be distilled into a particular catechesis—though it may be that such a stance reveals a lack of neutrality toward religion. But supporting a process that interrogates a prospective tenant’s religious views solely because it is a church tends to underline the questioner’s bias toward religion….

Although I find that a majority of voting members acted with bad motive, which would be enough on its own to end the inquiry, I also consider the deliberations’ context, where Walsh openly voiced anti-religious sentiment as the school’s representative and as someone who reflected the community’s discomfort should the Church’s beliefs conflict with the School’s. Even if the record did not establish a majority acting with bad motive, it would still show a substantial bloc of lawmakers and “circumstances suggesting the probable complicity of others,” along with evidence that the lawmakers aligned with an impermissible community animus.

Recall that Walsh relayed student concerns about using Hermon High School as a venue for the Church and, when asked if any students supported the idea, he reported that none did. Also recall the former committee member’s email implying that this was a Trojan horse guided by conservative Christian groups to blur the line between school and religion. What would the Committee do if an Imam opened a mosque at Hermon High School next?

The standard is likelihood; on that basis, I conclude that at least three of the five decision-makers acted with bad motive and thus violated the Plaintiffs’ First Amendment rights….

The defendant points to the majority vote in favor of a month-to-month arrangement as proof that there was no bias among committee members. I agree with the Church that this is not persuasive evidence of a lack of bad motive; rather, it supports the opposite conclusion. The Committee knew the church needed a more stable arrangement than month-to-month to leave its current space, and the offer appeared to be designed for rejection rather than reflecting sincere support for the Free Exercise Clause….

Bethany Onishenko and Robert H. Tyler (Tyler Law LLP), Erin Mersino and Julianne E. Fleischer (Advocates for Faith and Freedom), Joel L. Oster (Oster Law Firm), Wenonah Wirick (Conley & Wirick, P.A.) represented the plaintiffs.

Natalie Foster

I’m a political writer focused on making complex issues clear, accessible, and worth engaging with. From local dynamics to national debates, I aim to connect facts with context so readers can form their own informed views. I believe strong journalism should challenge, question, and open space for thoughtful discussion rather than amplify noise.