Florida City Halts Sponsorship of St. Patrick’s Day Parade Over New Anti-DEI Law

November 16, 2026

Even if private funding can keep the parade moving, the dispute exposes the statute’s sweeping wording and its baffling exemptions.

Recently, Delray Beach, a municipality in Florida, announced it would neither stage nor sponsor the upcoming St. Patrick’s Day parade, pointing to a new state statute that takes effect on January 1. The measure, Senate Bill 1134, bars local governments from “promoting, or granting preferential treatment or special benefits to a person or group based on that person’s or group’s race, color, sex, ethnicity, gender identity, or sexual orientation.”

Delray Beach Mayor Tom Carney, a Republican, describes the decision as an illustration of the “unintended consequences” of SB 1134, a law aimed at DEI policies that irk Gov. Ron DeSantis. The governor accuses Carney of attempting to discredit the statute through “malicious compliance.” Whatever one makes of that exchange, the bottom line appears favorable for taxpayers, since Carney says the parade can still move forward with private funding, as it has for most of its history. Yet that reading is complicated by the law’s long and uneven catalog of exemptions, which draw distinctions with little apparent logic.

The withdrawal of public money for the parade “is not mandated by Florida law,” DeSantis wrote on X last Friday. “It’s just an attempt to make a political point—a point that legacy media will no doubt try to amplify. We’ve seen these stunts over the years. Rinse and repeat.”

Carney maintains that his legal concerns are genuine. “The governor may truly believe what he says, and I take him at his word,” the mayor told NPR. “Our city attorney reached a different conclusion.”

It is easy to understand why SB 1134 might give a lawyer pause. Besides its expansive phrasing, the potential penalties for noncompliance are formidable. The statute states that “any member of the governing body of a municipality or other municipal official acting in an official capacity who violates this section commits misfeasance or malfeasance in office,” implying that the governor could suspend such an official on that basis. The ACLU of Florida argues that this provision conflicts with the state constitution, which “authorizes suspension of elected municipal officers only upon indictment for a crime.”

State Rep. Rob Long, a Democrat whose district includes Delray Beach, said the parade dispute confirms his concerns about SB 1134. “Governor DeSantis calls it ‘malicious compliance,’” Long wrote on Instagram. “I call it the foreseeable consequence of a poorly crafted law. I opposed it, and I won’t let Tallahassee pin the mess on Delray Beach.”

That framing begs a straightforward question: what mess?

Carney said he’s hopeful the city can chart a path forward—and a way to preserve the event—NPR reports. “Carney, who has Irish ancestry, noted that the parade was privately run until roughly eight years ago—so returning to a private-sponsorship model would be a return to the parade’s origins.”

Carney added that the city’s announcement had triggered a flood of complaints from residents. “It felt like a call to action for me,” he told NPR. “The community really wants to have it, so we should proceed. We just need to fund it privately.”

Given the parade’s history and the local enthusiasm Carney cited, securing private funding does not seem an insurmountable task. Indeed, one might question why taxpayers with no special stake in the event should have borne the cost in the first place.

The same logic applies to Delray’s “June Pride celebrations,” which Carney also referenced. “We should celebrate these kinds of events because, in this country, people can hold them,” he told NPR. “In many other places, you can’t. We have remarkable freedoms here. And if the community wants something and it isn’t against public policy, I would support it as long as it’s funded privately. If we can do it, we should do it.”

There is a clear distinction between permitting an event, whether it honors Irish heritage or LGBTQ pride, and forcing taxpayers to fund it. Yet neither Carney nor DeSantis — who contends there’s no reason Delray Beach should refrain from subsidizing the St. Patrick’s Day Parade — seems troubled by that distinction.

The numerous exemptions in SB 1134 compound the confusion. It explicitly does not bar local governments from “recognizing or promoting holidays designated by federal law,” including Christmas, Columbus Day, Juneteenth, and Martin Luther King Jr. Day. It also allows local governments to recognize and promote “patriotic and national observances recognized by federal law,” which encompass 48 occasions spanning from American Heart Month to Wright Brothers Day, among them National Hispanic Heritage Month and Asian/Pacific American Heritage Month.

Also permissible: “recognizing or promoting state holidays and special observances designated by state law,” which include Juneteenth Day, Good Friday, and Florida Jewish History Month. There is also an exception for celebrating “the individuals and groups recognized and honored” by state-recognized “monuments, memorials, and museums,” including the Florida Black History Museum, the Florida African American Heritage Preservation Network, the Florida Slavery Memorial, the Florida Holocaust Memorial, the Florida Women’s Hall of Fame, the Cuban Heritage Trail, the Jewish Heritage Trail, and the Native American Heritage Trail.

All of these exceptions lend credibility to Carney’s argument, since neither St. Patrick’s Day nor Gay Pride Month appears on the specified lists. But no matter how arbitrary that may seem, the law explicitly does not preclude local governments from “issuing event permits in a content-neutral manner and providing public safety services.”

Opponents of the statute nonetheless warned that it could hinder recognition of occasions and causes not included in its lists. SB 1134 “could mean you can’t celebrate Women’s History Month or Women’s Equality Day or Diwali or Chinese New Year or Easter,” warned state Rep. Christine Hunschofsky (D–Parkland).

An undefined you is doing a lot of the heavy lifting in that sentence, since the relevant clause applies only to local governments and explicitly allows them to accommodate public events “in a content-neutral manner.” So even if Carney and Hunschofsky are correct that the law’s broad language could plausibly cover public funding for events commemorating occasions not on the official lists, the takeaway is not necessarily that you cannot celebrate those occasions.

As Carney and Hunschofsky interpret it, the ban on “preferential treatment or special benefits” simply means that supporters of those events must contribute their own dollars. In general, that seems a fair expectation. Still, the broad and varied exemptions that Florida lawmakers chose to include may raise constitutional questions.

Under the First Amendment and the Fourteenth Amendment’s guarantee of equal protection, the Florida ACLU argues that the statute cannot be read to prevent local governments from hosting or backing programming that reflects the community’s diversity. For instance, “if depictions of families headed by heterosexual couples are permissible, so should depictions of families headed by same-sex couples,” it noted. “If a library program about how the founders were influenced by the Roman Republic is permissible, so should be one about the influence of the Iroquois Confederacy.”

The Florida ACLU offered other examples that seem puzzling when weighed against SB 1134’s distinctions. “If an arts event celebrating Irish American contributions is permissible, so is one celebrating African American contributions,” it said. “Despite their apparent efforts, the State of Florida cannot effectively require that only white non-Hispanic men receive funding, promotion, and praise.”

If anything, the law’s exemptions appear to favor African American communities over Irish Americans, as illustrated by the Delray Beach controversy surrounding St. Patrick’s Day. And given the exemptions for various African American and Hispanic celebrations, it is hard to identify overt hostility toward those groups. Instead, it seems lawmakers, rushing to curb the impact of a broadly worded anti-DEI statute, produced lists that, in aggregate, make little sense from any viewpoint.

Natalie Foster

I’m a political writer focused on making complex issues clear, accessible, and worth engaging with. From local dynamics to national debates, I aim to connect facts with context so readers can form their own informed views. I believe strong journalism should challenge, question, and open space for thoughtful discussion rather than amplify noise.