Circuit Roundup: A weekly, nonexhaustive digest of federal appellate rulings

November 21, 2026

Out-of-control burns, misleading claims, and federal highway funding.

Delight in the newest edition of Short Circuit, a weekly feature assembled by a group at the Institute for Justice.

Victory! Millions of Americans rely on and seek out low-FODMAP foods, which contain reduced amounts of certain sugars that can trigger painful digestive problems, aggravate irritable bowel syndrome, and worse. Happily, this week (following the Ninth Circuit’s revival of our First Amendment challenge), the FDA rescinded its prohibition on producers truthfully labeling their products as “Low-FODMAP.” IJ client Michelle Przybocki, who sticks to a strict low-FODMAP regime after nearly succumbing to digestive complications, remarks, “I’m thrilled that the federal government will permit firms to begin marking their products as ‘Low-FODMAP,’ because it makes it easier for me to locate foods I know won’t trigger my digestive issues.” Click here to learn more.

New to the Short Circuit podcast: Fancy a mid-morning Elevenses? We’re serving Eleventh Circuit insights in our #12Months12Circuits series. There’s talk of excessive bail in Alabama and inflated bar fees in Florida.

  1. A man with two DUIs from decades ago in Massachusetts relocates to New Hampshire and attempts to purchase a firearm, but is refused under the federal restriction on felons obtaining guns. He sues to challenge both the purchasing ban and the possession ban. The district court dismissed the case. The First Circuit noted that while there might be standing regarding the purchase aspect, he hasn’t alleged intent to possess a firearm that has travelled in interstate commerce, and perhaps no actual firearm is out there. Consequently, no standing for that claim. Regarding the purchase claim, standing might exist since he was explicitly prevented from buying a gun. The court vacated and remanded.
  2. A cop killer who spent 26 years in solitary confinement in a Connecticut prison. Was that cruel and unusual punishment? The jury declined to find it so. The district court called it a miscarriage of justice. The Second Circuit affirmed the grant of a new trial.
  3. FMCSA rules allow states to issue commercial driver’s licenses to noncitizens so long as the individual was lawfully present when issued and the license expires within eight years. New York issues initial licenses for five years. In 2025, the FMCSA reinterprets the rule to require expiry to align with lawful status, withholding $73 million in federal highway funds from New York. The Second Circuit asks, “Is that requirement actually in the regulations?” The FMCSA replies, “Not exactly.” The court concludes that the agency has effectively lost the argument.
  4. Kalshi and prediction markets: the Fourth Circuit (per curiam) holds that the Dodd-Frank Act does not preempt Maryland’s sports-gambling framework. Concurrence 1: Our judgment rests on preemption being absent. Concurrence 2: It’s not about swaps after all. Dissent: They are swaps (excluding parlays and props), and thus preempted.
  5. Under the False Claims Act of 1863, ordinary citizens can file fraud claims on behalf of the United States, but the U.S. government retains considerable latitude to assume control of or dismiss those claims. The Fifth Circuit’s decision concerns assertions of irregularities in Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine trials. Concurrence 1 suggests, though this mechanism has existed for a long time, these lawsuits may violate multiple constitutional provisions. Concurrence 2: That argument merits en banc consideration in an appropriate case.
  6. The district court blocked Mississippi’s online age-verification law as applied to certain websites managed by members of the plaintiff trade association. The Fifth Circuit explains that the district court failed to conduct the robust, fact-centric analysis needed to show why the Act is unconstitutional as applied to each member site. The case is vacated for a more precise evaluation of those particular sites. (And yes, district court staff, they’re all pretty safe for work—depending on who you follow.)
  7. Is Tennessee’s present sex-offender registry system in violation of the Ex Post Facto Clause? The Sixth Circuit notes that, with respect to the named government official, the action simply publicly labels someone as an “OFFENDER AGAINST CHILDREN.” It isn’t obvious that this, in itself, constitutes punishment. However, the portions of the statute that significantly restrict where plaintiffs may reside and with whom they may associate suggest a closer look, implying the plaintiff may have targeted the wrong official.
  8. A man slumps in the driver’s seat of a running, parked pickup and is incoherent; deputies from Sullivan County, Tennessee, attempt to pull him from the vehicle and a struggle ensues. An officer yells “Gun!” and fires twice, apparently missing, and a second officer shoots the man, who dies. The gun was found in his right pocket, and his right hand grasped the headrest behind him as he was shot. The district court denied qualified immunity, sending the case to trial. The Sixth Circuit (2-1, unpublished) reversed, remanding for consideration of state-law immunity issues.
  9. Relying on unsworn tips and boilerplate language, a St. Louis detective obtains a warrant for a no-knock raid. SWAT teams light up the home with flashbangs and fatally strike a 60-something who was partially blind and partially deaf, and relied on caregivers—not someone suspected of dealing drugs. The officers claim he fired at them, a claim that’s hotly disputed. The Eighth Circuit finds the evidence not genuinely in dispute.
  10. In 2022, after the U.S. Forest Service conducted controlled burns in New Mexico, the events spiraled into an out-of-control situation, prompting Congress to pass a law offering expedited compensation for those affected outside standard tort litigation. The question remains whether compensation includes noneconomic damages. The Tenth Circuit answers no, reads any ambiguity against a waiver of sovereign immunity. A dissent argues the statute compensates for all “injuries,” which would include non-economic harms.
  11. A group of friends argues that it’s wrong and historically inaccurate for government officials who lie under oath to be shielded from civil liability, leaving a virtually non-existent avenue for accountability. The Eleventh Circuit (unpublished) cautions against declaring a zero-chance outcome outright.
  12. According to the Eleventh Circuit (unpublished), if a body lies inside a home, officers may enter without a warrant. That ruling seems reasonable to some, but it’s difficult news for the plaintiff in a case involving the loss of a daughter who had been receiving in-home hospice care in Boynton Beach, Florida.
  13. On en banc review, the Second Circuit (with a fiery dissent) declines to revisit its decision that three Amish schools in New York must obey a state law that eliminated religious exemptions from vaccination requirements (carrying penalties of up to $2,000 per student per day).
  14. In yet more en banc developments, the Third Circuit (in a sharply worded dissent) will not reconsider its ruling that a church—whose shrine-building ambitions seem to have been disrupted in retaliation for its anti-abortion advocacy—should not yet obtain a preliminary injunction to proceed.
  15. In a further en banc matter, the Third Circuit (9-3) will not revisit its opinion that a New Jersey congresswoman, indicted for assaulting federal agents at an immigration detention facility, is not shielded by legislative immunity.
  16. In additional en banc news, the Fifth Circuit (amid a forceful dissent) will not reassess its holding that a Houston SWAT officer acted reasonably in shooting a man who had already been shot eight times but was still moving, in the back of the neck and head, resulting in his death.

Friends, when a federal official breaches your constitutional rights, the options to seek redress through monetary damages have dwindled in recent times, effectively granting the feds near-absolute immunity for many forms of misconduct. Yet there must be some route to accountability. At IJ, we’re pushing back not only against the now-departed Bivens remedy but also against the overly narrow interpretation of the Federal Tort Claims Act. And we also highlight the traditional accountability mechanisms that the Founders would have recognized—and that the Supreme Court’s Bivens skeptics favored—state-law actions such as California’s longstanding tort regime and the state’s Bane Act. All of these avenues were discussed during oral arguments in the Ninth Circuit this week, where we were glad to see a lively, cross-ideological panel. Click here to learn more.

Natalie Foster

I’m a political writer focused on making complex issues clear, accessible, and worth engaging with. From local dynamics to national debates, I aim to connect facts with context so readers can form their own informed views. I believe strong journalism should challenge, question, and open space for thoughtful discussion rather than amplify noise.