From Chief Judge James Boasberg of the D.C.C. today in Doe v. Trump:
Michael Doe, an American citizen, has his spouse and daughter residing in Kyiv, Ukraine. In March 2025, his wife and child narrowly escaped a drone assault. On his own behalf and for a class of Ukrainian refugees, Doe brings suit against President Trump, Secretary Rubio, and Elon Musk, alleging violations, among others, of a federal statute imposing sanctions on Russia, the Take Care Clause, and the First Amendment. [The allegations appear to connect to the Trump Administration’s sanctions on Russia, Musk’s conduct regarding Ukraine, and the Starlink program. -EV]
Generally, a complaint must identify who the plaintiffs are. That requirement reflects a presumption favoring the disclosure of litigants’ identities, rooted in the public’s interest in the openness of governmental processes and, more precisely, in the tradition of transparent judicial proceedings. Consequently, a party seeking permission to proceed pseudonymously carries a significant burden to show a concrete need for such secrecy and to specify the consequences that would likely result if the case proceeded under a fictitious name.
Here, the plaintiff has not shown that his interest in anonymity outweighs the public interest in learning his identity.
The Court recognizes the brutal, life-threatening dangers faced by residents of Kyiv, and it does not take their safety concerns lightly, nor those of their families. Yet the plaintiff fails to connect those legitimate fears to his own public designation in this lawsuit. He offers no evidence that Russia’s extensive bombing campaign targets family members of individuals pursuing sanctions-related lawsuits in the United States. At most, he asserts that “[t]he Russian government has a well-documented history and pattern of targeting anyone, anywhere in the world, who challenges their authority,” including documented assassination attempts and the use of sophisticated hacking groups to steal identities, digital assets, and to launch drone strikes inside Ukraine.
Doe’s broad claim that Russia retaliates against critics does not establish that it will assassinate him, steal his identity or digital assets, or launch drone strikes at his family members in Ukraine in response to a lawsuit. Absent specific threats or evidence that his family members will be targeted in this manner, this factor weighs against allowing pseudonymity.