Establishment Clause Violated by the Secretary of Agriculture’s Christian Messages to Employees

November 20, 2026

A federal court issued a ruling today in the case Nat’l Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, delivered by Judge Trina Thompson of the Northern District of California. The decision centers on the proper boundaries for religious messaging within official government communications and lays out concrete limitations on how the Secretary of Agriculture may engage with employees when her faith is discussed or promoted in an official context.

The top of the Secretary’s Easter message.

Departing from Judge Trina Thompson’s courtroom today in Nat’l Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Dep’t of Agriculture, the court addressed the boundaries surrounding religious expression in official communications and the potential for coercion within the workplace.

The Court ORDERS that the Secretary must observe clear limitations when sending religious messages through official channels. It held that she must stop when a colleague requests an end to such messages, cannot create a hostile work environment through persistent unwelcome religious conduct, and cannot leverage official authority to pressure subordinates. The court referred to USDA Secretary’s Memorandum 1078-019 in spelling out that the Secretary may discuss her religious beliefs with interested colleagues, share why her faith holds personal significance, extend polite invitations to religious services or events, and express religious viewpoints in appropriate conversations. The court also noted that it did not reach a determination about what the Secretary can or cannot do in a personal capacity outside of her official duties.

On July 4, 2025, Secretary Brooke Rollins sent an Independence Day message from her official account to the entire USDA workforce, concluding with a statement invoking divine protection over the United States. On November 26, 2025, she sent a Thanksgiving message from her official account, attributing some of the holiday’s origins to gratitude toward a loving God.

Two additional communications were identified as explicitly promoting Christianity. On December 23, 2025, Rollins emailed USDA employees with a Christmas message containing a video in which she asserted that the spirit of generosity originated with the first Christmas—the gift of God’s Son, Jesus Christ, who came to redeem humanity—calling this the reason for the season.

On April 5, 2026, she sent an Easter email addressed to “All USDA Employees” that began with “Team USDA” and declared “Happy Easter – He is Risen indeed!”. The message celebrated Easter as the central narrative of Christian faith, tracing the arc from Good Friday to the empty tomb and asserting that Jesus’ resurrection granted believers victory and new life, with life and hope accompanying risen life. It continued with a call to recognize Easter as a source of Paschal joy and a reminder of the mission to which each employee is called. The email closed with expressions of gratitude for employees’ hard work and a blessing for the USDA, the nation, and the people it serves, framed within a religious blessing and invocation of God’s favor.

At the top of the Easter message, the email featured an illustration depicting the stone rolled away from Jesus’ tomb, accompanied by the caption “Christ is Risen.”

Plaintiffs allege that Rollins has not sent comparable messages recognizing holidays of other faiths. They contrast these communications with USDA’s November 20, 2025 guidance on religious expression, which states that officials cannot use official authority to pressure subordinates regarding religious beliefs and must stop if a colleague asks to stop. They also contend that Rollins publicly defended the Easter message and is likely to send similar messages for future Christian holidays.

Each plaintiff read the challenged messages. The plaintiffs claim that they were compelled to read them because such communications could carry consequential operational information, including notices about agency reorganizations, employee relocations, changes to USDA’s civil rights program, shutdown planning, and the Deferred Resignation Program, with holiday messages historically serving to announce administrative leaves.

The individual plaintiffs argue that the messages conveyed a preference for employees who share the Secretary’s Christian beliefs, created feelings of exclusion for those who hold different beliefs, and pressured coworkers to conceal their beliefs or pretend to share hers. They fear disfavor and retaliation for objecting, and the complaint even alleges warnings from supervisors that objections would cause “trouble.” One plaintiff, Poopatanapong, says she no longer feels safe discussing a Buddhist holiday she observes; another, Roberts, an atheist, feels silenced; Wolfe, a practitioner of Pagan beliefs, experiences pressure to appear Christian for career advancement. They also contend that USDA members throughout the agency similarly received the messages, felt compelled to read them, and faced pressure to accept the Secretary’s beliefs while withholding their own.

The court held that the plaintiffs’ Establishment Clause claims were likely to succeed.

The Establishment Clause guards religious freedom by demanding a separation between church and state. It prohibits government sponsorship, financial support, or active involvement in religious activity. Yet the Court acknowledged that the clause does not compel the government to purge all religious references from the public sphere, so long as such references do not amount to endorsement or indoctrination. In Kennedy v. Bremerton School District (2022), the Court recognized that the clause does not require removing every trace of religion from public life, but courts must remain vigilant to ensure that expressions of religion do not morph into coercive state action or indoctrination. The Court also cited Cutter v. Wilkinson (2005) in emphasizing the need for caution when evaluating the line between tolerant expression of religious views and policy that could coerce.

To assess Establishment Clause violations, the Court grounded its reasoning in an original-meaning and historical-context framework. This approach looks to the Framers’ understanding of the First Amendment’s relation between government and religion and considers historical practices that endured over time. If a government practice was accepted by the Framers and has withstood enduring scrutiny, it generally does not violate the Establishment Clause, though it is not sufficient to rely on history alone; the analysis must consider long-standing legal traditions.

Historically, coercion has been the defining feature of unconstitutional government conduct under the Establishment Clause. The Founders, including James Madison and Thomas Jefferson, warned against both direct religious coercion and subtler forms of pressure. Madison’s Memorial and Remonstrance Against Religious Assessments warned that official support for one faith risks pressuring others to conform, while Jefferson warned about anti-religious coercion through public opinion and other indirect means. The court invoked these arguments, noting their relevance to today’s question of whether official communications can impose a particular faith on a broad employee base. Madison’s call for equal protection of every person’s right to practice religion, without enabling any sect to dominate, remains a guiding principle.

According to the court, Rollins appears to have leveraged her official position to convey a religious message that extended beyond holiday greetings and veered into coercion. Three factors informed the court’s conclusion: (1) the Secretary’s position of authority, (2) the use of official email to reach the entire USDA workforce, and (3) the language in the messages that alienated employees who did not share the Secretary’s faith. The court noted that the third factor—through phrases like “our Savior Jesus Christ” and references to a shared, corporate mission rooted in Christian belief—suggested a universal alignment with the Secretary’s religious viewpoint. The court found that such language could reasonably be read as implying that all USDA staff must adhere to the same Christian creed in order to fulfill their roles, thereby violating the principle that government should avoid endorsing one faith over others. The court observed that, by casting the agency’s work as a mission aligned with a specific religious perspective, the Secretary conveyed a message that the government’s purpose included promoting that faith. The court also remarked that statements from the Secretary indicating a personal commitment to evangelism further underscored the coercive effect of the communications. The court clarified that it is not attempting to regulate the Secretary’s personal religious beliefs, but rather to ensure that the Secretary adheres to the agency’s own guidelines restricting religious messaging in official communications. The court viewed the April 5, 2026, and December 23, 2025 messages as crossing the line into coercive encouragement of conformity, thereby constituting an Establishment Clause violation.

In sum, while the court did not condemn religious sentiment itself, it ruled that the Secretary’s official outreach went too far when it used the machinery of government to push a particular faith on employees. The court did not require an administrative overhaul of religious expression in general but demanded strict compliance with the agency’s policy to prevent coercive messaging in the future. The decision underscores the principle that government communications must avoid placing employees in a position where they feel compelled to align with a particular religious viewpoint in order to advance professionally.

Natalie Foster

I’m a political writer focused on making complex issues clear, accessible, and worth engaging with. From local dynamics to national debates, I aim to connect facts with context so readers can form their own informed views. I believe strong journalism should challenge, question, and open space for thoughtful discussion rather than amplify noise.