Cyber Monday is approaching, signaling the peak period for shipments. While FedEx and UPS are increasing their winter rates by about 5.9 percent, Amazon has been moving more goods for less money. In the previous year, the company handled more parcels than either FedEx or UPS while earning less than half as much revenue per parcel as those rivals. Amazon relies on a network of local delivery service partners (DSPs) to enable this model. Yet New Jersey asserts that this innovative distribution system violates antitrust laws.
In August, the state’s attorney general, Jennifer Davenport, filed what her office describes as the first monopsony case brought by a state. Davenport accuses Amazon of suppressing drivers’ pay by dissuading each contractor from recruiting drivers from other contractors and calls for unspecified “structural relief” that could overhaul Amazon’s entire network of small delivery contractors.
Those contractors handle the most expensive and complex part of shipping: the last mile—the leg from the local warehouse to the customer’s porch. Even New Jersey’s complaint labels it “one of the most complex aspects of supply-chain management.” Amazon built its network to tackle that problem: it provides the routing software and partners with local companies to hire the drivers. Because of this unique system, New Jersey argues Amazon has created a market of its own. The state conveniently excludes large delivery-driver employers like FedEx, UPS, and the USPS, effectively branding Amazon as a monopsonist by definition. But demonstrating that a company dominates a market created around itself proves difficult. A true monopsony exists when a buyer is so dominant that sellers have few, if any, alternatives. In the state’s description, those sellers are the delivery drivers.
So do delivery drivers truly have no other choices? New Jersey contends that companies such as FedEx and UPS should not count as competitors because they do not hire enough drivers, or hire them quickly enough, for Amazon drivers to switch jobs reliably. Yet some friction in changing jobs is present across industries and does not establish monopsony power. Broader evidence suggests a competitive market for delivery drivers. The Labor Department notes that delivery-driver roles typically require a high school diploma, a clean driving record, and about a month of on-the-job training, with projections of roughly 152,700 openings every year through 2035.
Moreover, Amazon’s DSPs do not act as a single employer but compete vigorously with each other for drivers. New Jersey’s own complaint describes contractors “poaching drivers with better terms.” Those contractors “complained about competition for drivers,” with one owner asking Amazon to stop rivals “from poaching my drivers.” That competition manifests in wages uncharacteristic of a monopsony. Amazon says its contractors’ drivers will average nearly $24 an hour next year, more than $2 per hour above the Labor Department’s median for light-truck drivers.
The rest of the case targets conduct that is either beyond the scope of antitrust law or procompetitive. The state accuses Amazon of discouraging drivers from unionizing. Whatever the merits, that is a labor dispute for the National Labor Relations Board. Davenport also objects to Amazon’s preference for a network of small contractors because, as an internal document allegedly states, they lack “the scale to dictate terms.” Keeping production costs low and reducing the risk of service disruption obviously benefits consumers. Nevertheless, New Jersey favors larger contractors who “could potentially negotiate more competitive compensation.”
While Davenport’s market definition is arguably narrow, her proposed remedies are sweeping: a corporate monitor paid for by Amazon; treble damages, punitive damages, and “the maximum civil penalties”; and, most consequentially, “structural relief,” which could remake the network into fewer, larger contractors, likely raising delivery costs and slowing service.
New York City wants to go even further by forcing Amazon to end its contractor program. Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s Delivery Protection Act would require Amazon to hire directly the drivers its contractors employ, effectively shutting down more than 40 local small businesses Amazon partners with. Amazon began warning New York shoppers this week that the bill could add as much as $5 to each order.
With its delivery system, Amazon has solved the hardest step of shipping. The company has made same-day delivery a common occurrence, and the network behind it supports at least 14,000 jobs in New Jersey alone. A labor monopsonist suppresses wages and hires fewer workers. Amazon’s DSP program has done the opposite of both.