Trump-Era DOJ Drops Bid to Halt Alaska Senate Certification in Voter-Confusion Case

November 19, 2026

The legal action never carried any real merit.

Mary Peltola (left) and Sen. Dan S. Sullivan (R-Alaska) (right). (Mattie Neretin – CNP/Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call/Newscom)

Earlier, I covered the Trump administration’s lawsuit aimed at stopping the formal certification of Alaska’s Senate race, and the district court’s rejection of that bid. The DOJ argued that delaying certification was necessary to prevent “voter confusion” stemming from two candidates bearing nearly identical names on the ballot. As I noted previously, Republican hopeful Dan J. Sullivan could be mistaken for Dan S. Sullivan, the sitting Republican senator, and some voters might have accidentally selected Dan J. when they meant to back Dan S.

Today, according to election-law scholar Rick Hasen, the DOJ filed a brief with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit urging dismissal of the case. They also seek to have the district court’s ruling set aside on procedural grounds (I’m not weighing in on whether that is appropriate).

This marks the conclusion of a lawsuit that was never a serious legal threat (and perhaps even too weak to deserve such a label). As explained in my earlier post about the district court decision and in a well-regarded amicus brief from Rick Hasen, the suit lacked any genuine merit, and a decision in its favor would have risked creating troubling precedent.

Moreover, the final tally shows that Democratic candidate Mary Peltola won an outright majority (roughly 50.1%), surpassing both Dan S. Sullivan and all other contenders combined. Consequently, even if every voter who chose Dan J. Sullivan had intended to back Dan S., the result would not have changed. Alaska’s ranked-choice voting system (which reallocates ballots when no candidate secures a majority in the first round) might have mitigated any potential impact, but no reallocation occurred because Peltola already held an absolute majority from the outset. This outcome likely contributed to DOJ’s decision to withdraw.

As I noted in an earlier discussion of the case, Democrats arguably share some responsibility for attempting to mislead voters in this manner, even though it seems unlikely to have altered the outcome (evidence suggests Dan J. appeared on the ballot as part of a Democratic strategy to siphon votes away from Dan S.). Yet, for reasons outlined in that post, this kind of tactic is far from the worst example of exploiting voter ignorance.

Peltola’s victory fit largely into the broader “Blue tsunami” that saw Democrats gain nine Senate seats, including in several states typically considered red. Some speculate her margin benefited from the extraordinary appeal of her pet lizard! And perhaps we could use more lizards on Capitol Hill.

Natalie Foster

I’m a political writer focused on making complex issues clear, accessible, and worth engaging with. From local dynamics to national debates, I aim to connect facts with context so readers can form their own informed views. I believe strong journalism should challenge, question, and open space for thoughtful discussion rather than amplify noise.