Will Baude’s Measure of Judicial Independence: When a Conservative Justice Stands Against Trump
Will Baude has published a fresh essay in the New York Times with the headline, “This Is What an Independent, Competent Supreme Court Looks Like.” The accompanying illustration shows a towering judge, confidently holding the line while people to the left and right pull at his robe in opposite directions. The judge’s face doesn’t resemble any current member of the Court, yet it could pass for Chief Justice Roberts. Baude’s argument is to praise the Court for its independence, yet the sole piece of evidence he adduces to prove that independence is that the Court’s conservatives have ruled against President Trump:
The left, understandably, objects strongly to the court’s recent decisions on abortion, the Voting Rights Act, the unitary executive and so forth. These rulings matter a great deal. But reformers of the Court nonetheless lack perspective. If Chief Justice John Roberts could compose an op-ed, one can imagine him saying: “What? Ruling against the administration’s use of the National Guard, against sweeping emergency tariffs and the attack on birthright citizenship, while also preserving the Federal Reserve’s independence and safeguarding the integrity of the midterm elections, wasn’t enough for you?”
The Court has pushed back against the administration in high-stakes matters on these issues over the past year, and it has done so with six justices appointed by members of the president’s party—three appointed by President Trump himself. . . .
Given the realities of a second Trump term, Baude argues, the Supreme Court is performing remarkably well. If anything, it deserves applause rather than censure.
Yet there are numerous problems with this line of argument.
We can start with the two most conservative figures on the Court, Justices Alito and Thomas. They sided with President Trump in every case Baude mentions—ranging from the National Guard decisions to tariff rulings, birthright citizenship issues, challenges to the Federal Reserve, and various election-related matters. Do their votes really undermine the notion of an independent Court? They have no obligation to Trump and demonstrated the nerve to resist the temptation to retire and thereby allow Trump two additional appointments. (That is a standard not shared by Justice Breyer with respect to President Biden.)
Furthermore, in each of those cases, one or more of the Trump appointees dissented alongside Alito and Thomas: Gorsuch dissented in Trump v. Illinois, Kavanaugh dissented in Learning Resources v. Trump, Gorsuch dissented in Trump v. Barbara, Gorsuch and Barrett dissented in Trump v. Cook, and so on. Do these dissents by the Trump picks not signal independence in those instances? Or should their votes against Trump in other matters balance out their votes with Trump here?
Justice Kagan herself underscored this point during remarks at the Ninth Circuit Judicial Conference. She asserted that the Court has “checked the executive branch” in “very significant cases.” She described the composition as a chief justice with a shifting array of associates around him. Indeed, she appears to view Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, and Barrett as a nearly interchangeable “floating cast of characters.” The liberal bloc tends to vote in near lockstep, but a conservative vote is always up for grabs. Tell us how you really feel, Elena. (I’ll revisit Kagan’s remarks at Catholic University in a future Civitas column.)
Baude jokes about the Chief Justice drafting an opinion for all the cases in which he authored the majority against Trump. But the reality is more peculiar than fiction. In truth, John Roberts writes opinion pieces every term. Everything he says and does seems tailored to sustain a superficial balance. He even bundles certain essays together (Slaughter and Cook) to maximize media attention. The bigger question remains: what would Justices Thomas and Alito write if they were free from constraints?
The criterion for independence cannot be measured by how often Trump loses. Justices Thomas and Alito contend that the law actually backs Trump in those matters. They would argue (likely) that their colleagues’ failure to demonstrate independence helps explain their own votes. Or, as Justice Alito notes in his new book, they are “insecure originalists.”
Baude’s essay also suffers from a pronounced case of false equivalence. He strains to cast doubt on both camps—from the right and from the left.
With their sweeping midterm triumph, Democrats are weighing a package of reforms to the Supreme Court. And it’s not just Democrats: in recent months the court has drawn calls for reform from both sides of the aisle. Some conservatives even entertain the idea of expanding the number of justices.
On the left, presidential contenders and current lawmakers have pushed for expanding the Court. On the right, some members of the House and Senate proposed a constitutional amendment to fix the Court at nine seats. Which conservatives have advocated for expanding the Court? Beyond a few MAGA banners, there aren’t many obvious names.
Baude continues:
Some on the right perceive these rulings as betrayals. Yet the right-wing critics fail to display patience or to grasp constitutional principle. Conservative legal thinkers spent two generations rightly emphasizing originalist interpretation and limited government. And while some on the right now wish to move away from these principles to frustrate conservative rule, what goes around comes around, and principles will prove more valuable in the long run.
It’s fairly evident that Baude is aiming his remarks at Trump, who has vented on X about how his appointees betrayed him. Shame on the former president for not possessing the patience of a tenure-track professor and for not reading the most recent Harvard Law Review. Let’s be real: Trump is a politician with two years left in office, and his time horizon and expectations diverge from those of academics. The underlying issue, of course, is that Thomas and Alito insist that originalist principles support the President. It is Chief Justice Roberts, the “Judge Hercules” in Baude’s universe, who avoids any kind of originalist jurisprudence.
Baude continues to highlight shortcomings of the Court. Yet these criticisms come from the liberal side as well. Essentially, everything he writes could be lifted from the liberal podcast Strict Scrutiny:
This is not to say the Court is flawless. It faces numerous difficult questions, and the justices are human and prone to temptation. They also struggle with the discretion involved in deciding when and how to rule, which can appear capricious or manipulatively strategic. These tensions are especially visible in the Court’s inconsistent treatment of precedents, in its selection of which cases to hear, and in the ongoing debates over its “shadow docket” (or interim orders docket, if you prefer).
Does Baude question the legitimacy of decisions like Obergefell, which overturned thousands of years of precedent to create a constitutional right without a clear basis in original meaning? Would that ruling justify calls for court reform?
In the end, Baude hints, almost in passing, that “modest court reform” might include term limits.
There is one reasonable argument for reform: it could have only a placebo effect—acting as a placebo that makes some people feel cured and convinces the public that all the problems attributed to the Court have been resolved. A few modest reforms, such as gifting caps or even term limits, could be largely harmless. If such reforms convince many Americans that the Court is better—more independent, less corrupt, and so forth—that would be beneficial for the country.
Baude does not specify whether term limits would require a constitutional amendment or could be instituted by statute. I suspect this fragment will become the most cited line from his essay. Describing term limits as “modest” essentially gives away the game. Baude suggests that term limits would make America great again!
Here is my bottom line. I would prefer that today’s justices fearlessly adhere to the Constitution’s meaning, regardless of political outcomes, rather than pretend to be independent to avoid opening the door to reform. What would be the consolation prize for faking independence? Baude proposes that term limits could be “harmless”—a kind of placebo meant to reassure the body politic. With allies such as these, who needs enemies? Judges cannot control political actors. They ought not to engage in such chess moves.
It would not surprise me if Chief Justice Roberts chooses to retire when a Democrat holds the presidency, thereby permanently boosting his reputation for independence. Progressives and their supporters would elevate Roberts to the Judicial Parthenon, alongside John Marshall and other luminaries. But John Glover isn’t fooling anyone.